What Makes the Best Vodka: An Objective Exploration

American Vodka

The best vodka is is highly subjective and may well be different for many people. However, there are several objective criteria to establish a baseline for what constitutes a high-quality vodka.

Vodka, a spirit cherished worldwide for its versatility and purity, has long been a subject of debate among connoisseurs and casual drinkers alike. The quest to determine the “best vodka” is as complex as the drink itself. At Felene Vodka, we pride ourselves on our expertise in the distillation of organic vodka from fermented sugarcane. This experience gives us a unique perspective on what constitutes the finest vodka. In this exploration, we will delve into objective criteria such as taste, smoothness, quality of ingredients, price, additive content, and certifications like organic and non-GMO, which collectively define the excellence of vodka.

Taste: The Primary Indicator of Quality

Taste is subjective, yet it remains the foremost criterion in evaluating vodka. The best vodkas boast a clean, crisp taste with a balanced flavor profile. They should be neither too harsh nor too bland, providing a pleasant drinking experience whether consumed neat or in cocktails.

Smoothness: A Measure of Distillation Purity

Smoothness in vodka is a direct result of meticulous distillation and filtration processes. A smoother vodka indicates fewer impurities, resulting in a more refined and enjoyable drinking experience. The best vodkas are those that glide effortlessly over the palate, leaving a gentle warmth rather than a harsh burn.

Understanding the “Number of Times Distilled” Claim in Vodka Labels

In the world of vodka, marketing claims often create a mystique around the product, with the “number of times distilled” being a prominent example. This addendum aims to demystify this claim and explain its actual relevance to vodka quality.

The Distillation Process: A Brief Overview

Distillation is a process used to purify alcohol by separating it from other components in the base mixture. This process is crucial in vodka production, as it determines the purity and smoothness of the final product.

Number of Times Distilled: What Does it Really Mean?

The “number of times distilled” is a term often found on vodka labels, usually implying a higher quality product. However, it’s essential to understand that this number is more about the process than an indicator of quality.

  1. Excessive Distillation and Base Product Impurities: A higher number of distillations often suggests that the base product had significant impurities, requiring multiple rounds of distillation to achieve the desired purity. While multiple distillations can remove unwanted flavors and impurities, they do not inherently make the distilled spirit superior. In fact, excessive distillation results in an over-processed expression of the spirit.
  2. The Law of Diminishing Returns: Beyond a certain point, additional distillation yields minimal improvement in purity or taste. The difference between a spirit distilled five times and one distilled ten times may be negligible in terms of overall quality and flavor profile.
  3. Marketing Gimmick: The emphasis on the number of distillations has become a marketing tactic. Brands often use high distillation numbers to suggest a premium quality product, but this is not necessarily a guarantee of superior taste or purity.

The True Measures of Vodka Quality

Rather than focusing solely on the number of distillations, consumers should consider other more critical factors:

  • Quality of Ingredients: The type and quality of the base ingredients play a crucial role in the final taste and purity of the vodka.
  • Water Quality: The water used in the vodka production significantly impacts its overall quality.
  • Filtration Process: The method and materials used for filtration can influence the smoothness and purity of the distilled spirit.
  • Craftsmanship and Production Techniques: The skill and techniques employed in the distillation process are vital in crafting a high-quality vodka.

Takeaway on Number of Times Distilled

In summary, while the “number of times distilled” is a part of the production process, it should not be viewed as a standalone measure of quality. This claim has become an overused marketing tool and can be misleading. As vodka enthusiasts and producers, we recommend looking beyond distillation numbers and focusing on the overall quality, ingredients, and production methods to truly appreciate and evaluate vodka.

Quality of Ingredients: The Foundation of Superior Vodka

The ingredients used in vodka production significantly influence its final quality. High-quality vodkas are often made from premium grains, potatoes, or, in the case of Felene Vodka, fermented sugarcane. The purity of the water used also plays a crucial role. The best vodkas use clean, mineral-rich water to achieve a perfect balance in taste and texture.

Price: A Reflection of Quality and Craftsmanship

While price is not always a direct indicator of quality, it often reflects the craftsmanship and care put into the production of the spirit. Premium vodkas tend to be priced higher due to the use of superior ingredients, advanced distillation techniques, and often, artisanal approaches to production.

A top quality, or “ultra-premium vodka can cost on average about $20 for a 750ML bottle. Any more than that and you’re likely over-paying.

Bottle Design and Packaging

A fancy bottle has nothing to do with quality and should be ignored when speaking about quality of the “juice” inside. As a rule of thumb, look for a crystal-clear bottle, it’s proof that the distiller has nothing to hide and shows-off the sparkling clarity of the product inside. An overly ornate bottle can add $5-$10 to the cost of a bottle that may contain an average or below average product.

Celebrity Endorsed Vodkas

This should be obvious, but here we are…this is another “keep moving, nothing to see here” situations. However, if you are a star-gazer and must have it, go ahead. But if you think that most celebrities understand the products they are endorsing, we have a bridge to sell you. That said, a brand endorsed by a celebrity does not necessarily make it bad either. One thing is for sure, you will pay an extra $5-$10 that goes into the pocket of a celebrity instead of an artisan master distiller. We’ll leave that one to your own discretion.

To be sure, there is nothing about attaching a celebrity’s name to a bottle of liquor that makes it higher quality or worth more than a non-celebrity-endorsed brand.

Additives: The Pursuit of Purity

The finest vodkas minimize the use of additives. Additives can alter the taste and quality of the spirit. Vodkas with the fewest additives are often more pure and of higher quality, offering a cleaner taste and a more authentic experience.

This is not an easy one. By law in the United States, regulators will allow up to 2 grams of sweetener and up to 1 gram of citric acid in a liter of vodka and producers are not obligated to disclose it. Look for statements that specifically say : “no additives”, “no added sugar”, etc. Felene adds nothing extra.

Organic and Non-GMO Certifications: A Commitment to Quality and Sustainability

Organic certification ensures that the ingredients used in the vodka are free from synthetic pesticides and fertilizers, while non-GMO certification guarantees that the ingredients are not genetically modified. These certifications not only reflect a commitment to environmental sustainability but also often result in a purer, more natural-tasting expression.

In conclusion, determining the “best vodka” is a multifaceted endeavor, hinging on various objective criteria. At Felene, we believe that the best vodka is one that excels in taste and smoothness, uses high-quality ingredients, offers value for its price, minimizes additives, and adheres to organic and non-GMO standards. As connoisseurs of this fine spirit, our mission is to continually strive for these standards, ensuring that every sip of Felene is an embodiment of excellence in distilling craftsmanship.

Kim Laderer

Kim Laderer-Veiga is the President of Felene Inc. Kim's unique and close-up knowledge of the on and off-premise alcohol business has given her a look into the trends and staples of the liquor industry. In the Kim Factor blog, Kim shares her expertise, her discoveries and her observations of the spirits business.

All author posts